Medically reviewed by Mary Choy, PharmD
Creatine supplements come in many forms, though pills and powders are the most common.
While they may offer the same benefits to your muscle mass and recovery, creatine powder and creatine pills can differ in their convenience, absorption rate, cost, and other factors that can help you decide which is right for you.
Comparison of Creatine Pills vs. Powder
Creatine pills and powder are both made of the same type of creatine, so taking either one is a great way to add more creatine to your routine. Still, there are a few differences to consider.
Composition and Ingredients
Most creatine products contain creatine monohydrate.
Other creatine forms
, like creatine ethyl ester and creatine nitrate, are also available, but research suggests they’re not as useful or safe as creatine monohydrate.
Creatine pills use the same creatine as creatine powder:
creatine monohydrate
. The pill product can press the creatine into a tablet or pack it into a capsule.
The other ingredients in any creatine supplement can vary. When comparing creatine-only powders to pills, the pills may have a few extra ingredients. These ingredients keep the pill stable and help it work as it should in your body. These ingredients are usually harmless, though they may be of concern if you have dietary restrictions or allergies.
Creatine may also be part of multi-ingredient products that include other fitness supplements and nutrients. Read product labels carefully to ensure you take the ingredients you are interested in taking.
Absorption and Bioavailability
Bioavailability refers to how much of a drug your body can break down, absorb, and use. The bioavailability of creatine can vary by form.
Powder:
You dissolve creatine powder into liquid before you take it. This helps your body absorb the nutrients quickly and easily.
Pills:
Your body takes longer to break down and absorb creatine in pill form, which may slow down how quickly the creatine takes effect. This is because acids in your stomach and digestive tract need to dissolve the pill first, and most pills have a coating or capsule to keep their shape until they reach your stomach. Slower breakdown also means you may have fewer side effects.
Convenience and Lifestyle Fit
Considering your lifestyle demands can also help you decide between creatine forms.
Powder:
Before you take creatine powder, you must mix it with a liquid, like water, juice, or a shake. Depending on your diet and schedule, this can be a quick addition to your routine. Creatine powder products usually come in large bulk containers, though travel-size packets are also available.
Pills:
Creatine pills do not need to be mixed and are easy to carry and take anywhere.
Dosage Accuracy
The different forms may offer different flexibility in how much you take.
Powder:
Creatine powder lets you tailor how much you take to meet your specific needs. Most products come with a measuring scoop, or you can use teaspoons or tablespoons. Read the label or talk with a SnapUpdateNowcare provider to determine how much you should take. The strength of the powder may depend on the brand and product you use.
Pills:
Creatine pills come in specific strengths, depending on the product you buy. Your dosage must come in multiples of the pill’s strength, which may offer less flexibility.
Cost Considerations
The cost of creatine may differ by form.
Powder:
Powder is typically the most cost-friendly version of creatine. Creatine powder is available in bulk, so you get more product for your money. The powder form is also usually the most stable and lasts the longest without degrading or breaking down.
Pills:
Pills may be more expensive because they are not bulk buys.
Pros and Cons
The advantages and disadvantages of creatine powder vs. pills may depend on your individual needs and goals.
Creatine Powder Pros
The benefits of creatine powder include:
- You can mix creatine powder with liquid products you take daily, like water, juice, or shakes.
- Your body absorbs creatine faster from powder form than pill form.
- You can easily customize how much creatine powder you take.
Creatine Powder Cons
Potential downsides of creatine powder include:
-
Creatine powder may sometimes cause digestion issues and side effects, such as bloating, weight gain (due to extra
water retention
), diarrhea, and nausea. - The taste or texture of a creatine supplement may be unpleasant, depending on the product you use.
- Preparing and mixing a creatine powder into liquid takes a bit of effort.
Creatine Pills Pros
The benefits of creatine pills and capsules include:
- You don’t need to mix creatine capsules, so they are easy to take at any time. Pills are also easier to carry and take on the go.
- Each pill has a specific amount of creatine, so you know you’re taking the same amount each time.
- Side effects are less likely.
- You won’t experience taste or texture issues with creatine pills.
Creatine Pills Cons
Potential downsides of creatine pills and capsules include:
- If you are taking a high dosage of creatine, you will likely need to take multiple pills.
- You have less flexibility in creating a specific creatine dose using pills.
- Because your body needs to break down the pill, it may take longer to absorb and see the benefits.
- Creatine pills usually cost more than powder products.
-
Taking creatine pills may be a challenge if you have
difficulty swallowing
.
How To Choose
Choosing creatine in a powder or pill may depend on your lifestyle, preferences, and fitness goals.
If you are interested in lower cost and more flexibility in how much you take, powder may be a better option for you.
If your interests are ease and convenience, creatine pills may be the right choice.
When buying a supplement, make sure the product is independently tested. Unlike medications, supplements are not regulated by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA). This means their quality and safety can vary. Independent testing confirms that the supplement contains the ingredients listed on the label and is free from harmful contaminants. Check for seals from reputable organizations such as NSF International, USP (United States Pharmacopeia), or ConsumerLab.
Other Considerations
The usual recommended creatine dosage is a loading dose of 20 grams a day for seven days, then 3-5 grams a day for up to 12 weeks. The seven-day loading dose helps quickly raise creatine levels, helping you see benefits sooner. Studies have shown that the supplement is safe to use for several years.
Your creatine levels rise for 3-4 hours after taking creatine. However, taking the product consistently is most useful in maintaining your creatine levels. If you want the supplement to work well, it is important to:
- Take it consistently
- Exercise regularly
- Stay hydrated to help lower the risk of side effects or muscle stiffness
A Quick Review
The best form of creatine for you likely depends on your lifestyle, preferences, and fitness goals. If you are interested in keeping costs to a minimum and having more control over how much you take, powder may be ideal. If you prefer ease and convenience, creatine pills may be the right choice.
Read the original article on
SnapUpdateNow